The New York Yankees’ prospects for the 2025 season have suffered a setback as star pitcher Gerrit Cole is once again experiencing elbow issues. With Opening Day just around the corner, there is growing concern that the reigning AL Cy Young Award winner may need surgery, which could keep him out of action for a significant portion of the season.
Yankees captain Aaron Judge sought to ease worries about Cole’s situation, sharing a positive outlook after speaking privately with the pitcher. “We’ll be in a good spot,” Judge told reporters. “He’s a tough guy. We’ll see what happens.” Despite Judge’s optimism, Cole’s potential absence would create a major gap in the Yankees’ pitching rotation, prompting the team to consider internal alternatives or look for external solutions through trades. This could mean younger pitchers might be thrust into the spotlight sooner than anticipated, adding pressure to a roster already grappling with multiple injuries.
Gerrit Cole is scheduled to undergo an MRI on his right elbow after reporting discomfort. His recent spring training performance, where he gave up six runs, has only heightened concerns. (@JonHeyman, March 8, 2025)
The Yankees’ injury woes don’t end with Cole. Giancarlo Stanton, the team’s power hitter, is once again struggling with fitness issues, while AL Rookie of the Year Luis Gil is expected to miss at least three months due to a right lat strain. Additionally, DJ LeMahieu, JT Brubaker, and top pitching prospect Chase Hampton are also on the injured list, compounding the team’s challenges.
As the Yankees gear up for the 2025 season, their championship hopes are in jeopardy. The front office faces critical decisions in the weeks ahead, and how they address these obstacles could determine the success—or failure—of their campaign. The team’s ability to adapt and overcome these setbacks will be crucial in their pursuit of a title.
